Balloon expandable vs Self-Expanding Valves: The Best Option for ViV-TAVR in Small Annuli

TAVR has consolidated as an increasingly valid alternative to treat failed surgical aortic valve bioprostheses.  

Balón-expandible vs autoexpandible: ¿cuál es la mejor opción para V-in-V en anillo pequeño?

One of the major challenges it presents is patients with small annuli treated with a surgical bioprosthesis. 

There is little data available about this scenario. A few observational studies have shown what appears to be a hemodynamic advantage of self-expanding valves (SEV) over balloon-expandable valves (BEV). 

A randomized, prospective, controlled study was carried out comparing BEV SAPIEN (3/ULTRA from Edwards Lifesciences) vs SEV Evolut (R/PRO/ PRO+ from Medtronic) in patients with a small annulus receiving a bioprosthesis with 23 mm annulus or with 21 mm internal diameter.  

BEV were 20 or 23 mm and SEV were 23 mm or 26 mm.

Read also: Clinical Results of IVUS-Guided Drug-Eluting Stent Implantation in Femoropopliteal Disease

Primary end point was maximal and mean residual gradient, prosthetic mismatch (PPM) or moderate / severe aortic regurgitation at 30 days, assessed by eco-Doppler.

102 patients were randomized, but only 98 were included, seeing as two died prior procedure and two received medical treatment and no intervention. 46 patients received BEV, and 52 SEV. 

Mean age was 80, nearly half were men and there were no differences in comorbidities. Kidney function deterioration occurred in 45% of patients and STS was 5%.

Valves most frequently failed were the 21 and 23 mm, followed by 19 and 22 mm.

Read also: Surgical Bioprosthesis Deterioration: Is the Valve-in-Valve Technique a Good Option?

The most common dysfunction was stenosis (66.7%), the rest was regurgitation, and bioprosthesis failure was diagnosed 11 years after surgery. 

Left ventricular ejection fraction was 58%, AVAO 0.93 cm2 and gradients were 70/43 mmHg.

The approach was transfemoral in 90% of patients. There were no differences in pre or post dilation and annulus fracture was more frequent in the BEV group (30% vs. 13% P=0.04).

Procedure was successful in all patients. 

SEV patients had lower maximal and mean gradient (15±5 mmHg vs 23±8 mmHg P<0.001 and 28±16 vs 40±13 P<0.001), a tendency toward lower severe PPM (44% vs 64% P=0.07) and there was no moderate / severe regurgitation. 55 patients (27SEV and 28BEV) underwent invasive valve hemodynamic evaluation during the procedure, with no differences in mean and peak transvalvular gradients between both groups. 

Read also: Left Atrial Appendage Closure Is Safe with the New Devices.

At 30 days there were no differences in mortality, stroke, MI, major bleeding (or life-threatening bleeding) need for pacemaker implantation or major vascular complications.

Conclusion

In patients with failed small bioprosthesis, ViV with SEV was associated with improved valve hemodynamics assessed by echocardiography. There were no differences between the groups in intra-procedural hemodynamics or 30-day evolution. 

Dr. Carlos Fava - Consejo Editorial SOLACI

Dr. Carlos Fava.
Member of the Editorial Board of SOLACI.org.

Original Title: Balloon- vs Self-Expanding Valve Systems for Failed Small Surgical Aortic Valve Bioprostheses. 

Reference: Josep Rodés-Cabau, et al. J Am Coll Cardiol 2022;80:681–693.


Subscribe to our weekly newsletter

Get the latest scientific articles on interventional cardiology

More articles by this author

Prospective Analysis of the Feasibility of the PASCAL System for Transcatheter Mitral Repair: OneForAll Registry

Courtesy of Dr. Juan Manuel Pérez. Mitral transcatheter edge-to-edge repair (M-TEER) is an effective option for patients with severe mitral regurgitation who are at high...

Left Bundle Branch Block after TAVR: What Is Its Impact?

Courtesy of Dr. Juan Manuel Pérez. Left bundle branch block (LBBB) is a common complication following transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR), which can be either...

Multicenter Experience with 3D Intracardiac Echocardiography for Guiding Interventional Cardiac Procedures

Courtesy of Dr. Juan Manuel Pérez. Imaging techniques play a fundamental role in interventional cardiac procedures. Intracardiac echocardiography (ICE) appears as an alternative to transesophageal...

Pathology of Self-Expanding Transcatheter Aortic Bioprostheses and Hypoattenuated Leaflet Thickening

Courtesy of Dr. Juan Manuel Pérez. Despite the available long term followup data on of transcatheter aortic valve replacement (TAVR), bioprosthesis durability continues under debate....

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Related Articles

SOLACI Sessionsspot_img

Recent Articles

ACC 2025 | FAME 3: FFR Guided PCI vs CABG 5 Year Outcomes.

Earlier studies comparing percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) vs coronary artery bypass graft (CABG) have shown fewer events at long term for the surgical strategy.  However,...

ACC 2025 | API-CAT: Reduced vs. Full Dose Extended Anticoagulation in Patients with Cancer Related VTE

The risk of cancer related recurrent venous thromboembolism (VTE) will drop over time, while bleeding risk will persist. At present, it is recommended we...

STRIDE: Semaglutide in Patients with Peripheral Arterial Disease and Type II Diabetes

Peripheral arterial disease (PAD) is a severe complication in patients with type II diabetes, primarily affecting peripheral vessels, especially below-the-knee (BTK) arteries. This condition...